Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer

Review article: Biomedical intelligence

Vol. 143 No. 3334 (2013)

Improving the organ donor card system in Switzerland

  • David Martin Shaw
DOI
https://doi.org/10.4414/smw.2013.13835
Cite this as:
Swiss Med Wkly. 2013;143:w13835
Published
11.08.2013

Abstract

This paper analyses the current organ donor card system in Switzerland and identifies five problems that may be partially responsible for the country’s low deceased organ donation rates. There are two minor issues concerning the process of obtaining a donor card: the Swisstransplant website understates the prospective benefits of donation, and the ease with which donor cards can be obtained raises questions regarding whether any consent to donation provided is truly informed. Furthermore, there are two major practical problems that might affect those who carry an organ donor card: the lack of a central donor registry increases the likelihood that donors’ wishes will be “lost”, and there is a high probability that family members will veto organ donation. The fact that these two practical problems are not mentioned to potential donors by Swisstransplant constitutes the fifth problem. Donation rates would probably improve if more accurate information about the benefits of donation were provided to potential donors, a central donor registry were created, and families were not permitted to veto donation from those on the registry.

References

  1. Swisstransplant. Annual Report, 2011. http://www.swisstransplant.org/l2/don-organe-transplantation-attribution-coordination-liste-attente-statistiques.php (Accessed 19 December 2012)
  2. Rosenblum AM,1 Ho-Ting Li A, Roels L, Stewart B, Prakash V, et al. Worldwide variability in deceased organ donation registries. Transpl Int. 2012;25(8):801–11.
  3. Swisstransplant. Organ donor card application form. http://www.swisstransplant.org/l2/organe-carte-de-donneur-transplantation-receveur-national-remplir-en-ligne.php (Accessed 19 December 2012)
  4. Gardiner D. An unethical marriage – the Human Tissue Act and the UK NHS Organ Donor Register. J Intensive Care Soc. 2007;8:42–3.
  5. Bell MDD. The UK Human Tissue Act and consent: surrendering a fundamental principle to transplantation needs? J Med Ethics. 2006;32:283–6.
  6. British Association of Critical Care Nurses. Briefing – organ donor registrations via the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency DVLA website. http://www.baccn.org.uk/news/10.04.19.OrgDonDVLA.asp (Accessed 19 December 2012)
  7. Swisstransplant. Organ donor card information leaflet. http://www.swisstransplant.org/pdf/BAG-Broschuere-f-web.pdf (Accessed 19 December 2012)
  8. Monteverde S, Rid A. Controversies in the determination of death: perspectives from Switzerland. Swiss Med Wkly. 2012;142:w13667.
  9. Rieke A, Regli B, Mattle HP, Brekenfeld C, Gralla J, Schroth G, Ozdoba C. Computed tomography angiography (CTA) to prove circulatory arrest for the diagnosis of brain death in the context of organ transplantation. Swiss Med Wkly. 2011;141:w13261
  10. Gardiner D. Private communication.
  11. Swiss Federal Government. Swiss Transplant Act. Section 8.2. http://www.admin.ch/ch/f/rs/810_21/a8.html (Accessed 19 December 2012)
  12. Shaw D. We should not let families stop organ donation from their dead relatives. BMJ. 2012;345:e5275.
  13. Seiler CA, Bischoff P, Nett PC, Candinas D. Abnehmende Organspendebereitschaft als nationales Problem: Im Engagement liegt der Lösungsansatz. Schweiz Ärzteztg. 2006;87:143–50.
  14. Human Tissue Authority. Code of practice 2: Donation of solid organs for transplantation. www.hta.gov.uk/legislationpoliciesandcodesofpractice/codesofpractice/code2donationoforgans.cfm
  15. Swisspod. Swisstransplant newsletter. June 2011, p.13. http://www.swisstransplant.org/pdf/swisstransplant-12-11-F.pd http://www.swisstransplant.org/pdf/swisstransplant-12-11-F.pdf f (Accessed 19 December 2012)
  16. Swissinfo. Organ shortfall being examined. http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/swiss_news/Organ_shortfall_being_examined_.html?cid=33439922 (Accessed 19 December 2012)
  17. World Radio Switzerland. Organ donation system riddled by red tape http://worldradio.ch/wrs/news/switzerland/organ-donation-system-riddled-by-red-tape.shtml (Accessed 19 December 2012)
  18. De Wispelaere J, Stirton L. Advance commitment: an alternative approach to the family veto problem in organ procurement. J Med Ethics. 2010;36:180–3.