Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer
##common.pageHeaderLogo.altText##

Review article: Biomedical intelligence

Vol. 144 No. 4546 (2014)

Eroding students’ rural motivation: first do no harm?

  • Samia Hurst
DOI
https://doi.org/10.4414/smw.2014.14020
Cite this as:
Swiss Med Wkly. 2014;144:w14020
Published
02.11.2014

Summary

Migration of health professionals is one of the drivers of vast inequalities in access to healthcare, as medical graduates tend to move away from both poorer countries and rural areas. One of the central ethical problems raised in attempting to alleviate these inequalities is the tension between the healthcare needs of under-served patients and the rights of medical graduates to choose their place of work and specialty. If medical graduates had greater motivation to work in under-served rural areas, this tension would decrease accordingly. Medical schools have a duty to avoid eroding existing motivation for such training and practice. This duty has practical implications. Medical students’ motivation regarding their choice of specialty changes during medical training, turning them away from choices such as primary care and rural practice towards more highly specialised, more hospital based specialties. Although students may be victims of a number of biases in the initial assessment, this is unlikely to be the whole story. Students’ priorities are likely to change based on their admiration for specialist role models and the visibility of the financial and non-financial rewards attached to these specialties. Students may also have a false expectation upon admission that they will be proficient in rural medicine on graduation, and change their mind once they realise the limits of their skills in that area. Although the measures required to reverse this effect currently lack a solid evidence base, they are plausible and supported by the available data.

References

  1. Crisp N, Chen L. Global Supply of Health Professionals. N Engl J Med. 2014;370:950–7.
  2. Mullan F. The metrics of the physician brain drain. N Engl J Med. 2005;353(17):1810–8.
  3. Eyal N, Barnighausen T. Precommitting to serve the underserved. Am J Bioeth. 2012;12(5):23–34.
  4. Frenk J, Chen L, Bhutta ZA, Cohen J, Crisp N, Evans T, et al. Health professionals for a new century: transforming education to strengthen health systems in an interdependent world. Lancet. 2010;376(9756):1923–58.
  5. World Health Organization. Transforming and scaling up health professionals’ education and training: World Health Organization guidelines 2013. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2013.
  6. Eyal N, Hurst SA. Scaling up changes in doctors’ education for rural retention: a comment on World Health Organization recommendations. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 2011;89(2):83.
  7. World Health Organization. Increasing access to health workers in remote and rural areas through improved retention. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2010.
  8. Clemens M. Do visas kill? Health effects of African health professional emigration. Center for Global Development, 2007.
  9. Aluwihare AP. Physician migration: donor country impact. J Contin Educ Health Prof. 2005;25(1):15–21.
  10. Taylor AL, Hwenda L, Larsen BI, Daulaire N. Stemming the brain drain--a WHO global code of practice on international recruitment of health personnel. N Engl J Med. 2011;365(25):2348–51.
  11. Kangasniemi M, Winters LA, Commander S. Is the medical brain drain beneficial? Evidence from overseas doctors in the UK. Soc Sci Med. 2007;65(5):915–23.
  12. Kollar E, Buyx A. Ethics and policy of medical brain drain: a review. Swiss Med Wkly. 2013;143:w13845.
  13. Sheikh A, Naqvi SHA, Sheikh K, Naqvi SHS, Bandukda MY. Physician migration at its roots: a study on the factors contributing towards a career choice abroad among students at a medical school in Pakistan. Globalization and health. 2012;8.
  14. Schrecker T, Labonte R. Taming the brain drain: A challenge for public health systems in Southern Africa. Int J Occup Env Heal. 2004;10(4):409–15.
  15. Ahmad OB. Managing medical migration from poor countries. Brit Med J. 2005;331(7507):43–5.
  16. Eyal N, Hurst SA. Physician Brain Drain: Can Nothing be Done? Public Health Ethics. 2008;1(2):180–92.
  17. Edge JS, Hoffman SJ. Empirical impact evaluation of the WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel in Australia, Canada, UK and USA. Globalization and health. 2013;9:60.
  18. Siyam A, Zurn P, Ro OC, Gedik G, Ronquillo K, Co CJ, et al. Monitoring the implementation of the WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel. B World Health Organ. 2013;91(11):816–23.
  19. Observatoire Suisse de la Santé (OBSAN). Le corps médical en Suisse: effectifs et évolution jusqu'en 2011. Neuchatel: OBSAN, 2012.
  20. Ricketts TC. The Migration of Physicians and the Local Supply of Practitioners: A Five-Year Comparison. Academic Medicine. 2013;88(12):1913–8.
  21. Coulter ID, Wilkes M, Der-Martirosian C. Altruism revisited: a comparison of medical, law and business students' altruistic attitudes. Med Educ. 2007;41(4):341–5.
  22. Gerke W, Rufer M, Schnyder U. Attracting young academics into the field of psychiatry and psychotherapy in Switzerland – The Zurich 'study focus on psychiatry' and training concept for medical psychotherapy. Int Rev Psychiatr. 2013;25(4):445–9.
  23. Baer LD, Ricketts TC, Konrad TR, Mick SS. Do international medical graduates reduce rural physician shortages? Medical Care. 1998;36(11):1534–44.
  24. Zinn WM, Sullivan AM, Zotov N, Peters AS, Connelly MT, Singer JD, et al. The effect of medical education on primary care orientation: results of two national surveys of students' and residents' perspectives. Academic medicine: J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2001;76(4):355–65.
  25. Puljak L, Brnjas Kraljevic J, Barac Latas V, Sapunar D. Demographics and motives of medical school applicants in Croatia. Medical teacher. 2007;29(8):e227–34.
  26. Odusanya OO, Alakija W, Akesode FA. Socio demographic profile and career aspirations of medical students in a new medical school. The Nigerian postgraduate medical journal. 2000;7(3):112–5.
  27. Sousa F, Jr., Schwalbach J, Adam Y, Goncalves L, Ferrinho P. The training and expectations of medical students in Mozambique. Hum Resour Health. 2007;5:11.
  28. Morley CP, Roseamelia C, Smith JA, Villarreal AL. Decline of medical student idealism in the first and second year of medical school: a survey of pre-clinical medical students at one institution. Medical education online. 2013;18:21194.
  29. Woloschuk W, Harasym PH, Temple W. Attitude change during medical school: a cohort study. Medical Education. 2004;38(5):522–34.
  30. Crandall SJS, Volk RJ, Cacy D. A longitudinal investigation of medical student attitudes toward the medically indigent. Teach Learn Med. 1997;9(4):254–60.
  31. Crandall SJS, Volk RJ, Loemker V. Medical-Students Attitudes toward Providing Care for the Underserved – Are We Training Socially Responsible Physicians. Jama-J Am Med Assoc. 1993;269(19):2519–23.
  32. Clark TR, Freedman SB, Croft AJ, Dalton HE, Luscombe GM, Brown AM, et al. Medical graduates becoming rural doctors: rural background versus extended rural placement. Med J Aust. 2013;199(11):779–82.
  33. World Health Organization (WHO). The World Health Report 2006: Working Together for Health. Geneva: WHO, 2006.
  34. Thompson MJ, Huntington MK, Hunt DD, Pinsky LE, Brodie JJ. Educational effects of international health electives on U.S. and Canadian medical students and residents: a literature review. Academic medicine: J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2003;78(3):342–7.
  35. Green T, Green H, Scandlyn J, Kestler A. Perceptions of short-term medical volunteer work: a qualitative study in Guatemala. Globalization and health. 2009;5:4.
  36. Green LA, Fryer GE, Jr., Yawn BP, Lanier D, Dovey SM. The ecology of medical care revisited. N Engl J Med. 2001;344(26):2021–5.
  37. Burack JH, Irby DM, Carline JD, Ambrozy DM, Ellsbury KE, Stritter FT. A study of medical students' specialty-choice pathways: trying on possible selves. Academic medicine: J Assoc Am Med Coll. 1997;72(6):534–41.
  38. Doty B, Heneghan S, Gold M, Bordley J, Dietz P, Finlayson S, et al. Is a broadly based surgical residency program more likely to place graduates in rural practice? World journal of surgery. 2006;30(12):2089–93.
  39. Erikson CE, Danish S, Jones KC, Sandberg SF, Carle AC. The role of medical school culture in primary care career choice. Academic medicine: J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2013;88(12):1919–26.
  40. Rosenthal MP, Diamond JJ, Rabinowitz HK, Bauer LC, Jones RL, Kearl GW, et al. Influence of income, hours worked, and loan repayment on medical students' decision to pursue a primary care career. JAMA. 1994;271(12):914–7.
  41. Kahn MJ, Markert RJ, Lopez FA, Specter S, Randall H, Krane NK. Is medical student choice of a primary care residency influenced by debt? MedGenMed: Medscape general medicine. 2006;8(4):18.
  42. Rosenblatt RA, Andrilla CH. The impact of U.S. medical students' debt on their choice of primary care careers: an analysis of data from the 2002 medical school graduation questionnaire. Academic medicine: J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2005;80(9):815–9.
  43. Grayson MS, Newton DA, Thompson LF. Payback time: the associations of debt and income with medical student career choice. Med Educ. 2012;46(10):983–91.
  44. Enoch L, Chibnall JT, Schindler DL, Slavin SJ. Association of medical student burnout with residency specialty choice. Medical Education. 2013;47(2):173–81.
  45. Newton DA, Grayson MS, Thompson LF. Money, lifestyle, or values? Why medical students choose subspecialty versus general pediatric careers. Clinical pediatrics. 2010;49(2):116–22.
  46. Buddeberg-Fischer B, Klaghofer R, Abel T, Buddeberg C. The influence of gender and personality traits on the career planning of Swiss medical students. Swiss Med Wkly. 2003;133(39–40):535–40.
  47. Clinite KL, Reddy ST, Kazantsev SM, Kogan JR, Durning SJ, Blevins T, et al. Primary care, the ROAD less traveled: what first-year medical students want in a specialty. Academic medicine: J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2013;88(10):1522–8.
  48. Hurst SA. What if medical graduates are right? Am J Bioeth. 2012;12(5):37–8.
  49. Christakis DA, Feudtner C. Ethics in a short white coat: the ethical dilemmas that medical students confront. Academic medicine: J Assoc Am Med Coll. 1993;68(4):249–54.
  50. Williamson MI, Wilson R, Mckechnie R, Ross J. Does the positive influence of an undergraduate rural placement persist into postgraduate years? Rural and Remote Health. 2012;12(2).
  51. Pacheco M, Weiss D, Vaillant K, Bachofer S, Garrett B, Dodson WH, et al. The impact on rural New Mexico of a family medicine residency. Academic Medicine. 2005;80(8):739–44.
  52. Talley BE, Ann Moore S, Camargo CA, Jr., Rogers J, Ginde AA. Availability and potential effect of rural rotations in emergency medicine residency programs. Academic emergency medicine: official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine. 2011;18(3):297–300.
  53. Huish R. How Cuba's Latin American School of Medicine challenges the ethics of physician migration. Soc Sci Med. 2009;69(3):301–4.
  54. Ferguson WJ, Cashman SB, Savageau JA, Lasser DH. Family medicine residency characteristics associated with practice in a health professions shortage area. Family medicine. 2009;41(6):405–10.
  55. D'Amore A, Mitchell EK, Robinson CA, Chesters JE. Compulsory medical rural placements: senior student opinions of early-year experiential learning. Aust J Rural Health. 2011;19(5):259–66.
  56. Pogge T. Real World Justice. The Journal of Ethics. 2005;9(1):29–53.
  57. Mackey TK, Liang BA. Restructuring brain drain: strengthening governance and financing for health worker migration. Global health action. 2013;6:1–7.
  58. Schneider A, Karsch-Volk M, Rupp A, Fischer MR, Drexler H, Schelling J, et al. Predictors of a positive attitude of medical students towards general practice – a survey of three Bavarian medical faculties. GMS Z Med Ausbild. 2013;30(4):Doc45.
  59. Henderson E, Berlin A, Fuller J. Attitude of medical students towards general practice and general practitioners. Br J Gen Pract.: J R Coll Gen Pract. 2002;52(478):359–63.
  60. Stagg P, Prideaux D, Greenhill J, Sweet L. Are medical students influenced by preceptors in making career choices, and if so how? A systematic review. Rural Remote Health. 2012;12:1832.
  61. Smith JK, Weaver DB. Capturing medical students' idealism. Ann Fam Med. 2006;4Suppl1:S32–7;discussionS58–60.
  62. Chan BT, Degani N, Crichton T, Pong RW, Rourke JT, Goertzen J, et al. Factors influencing family physicians to enter rural practice: does rural or urban background make a difference? Canadian family physician Medecin de famille canadien. 2005;51:1246–7.
  63. Hancock C, Steinbach A, Nesbitt TS, Adler SR, Auerswald CL. Why doctors choose small towns: a developmental model of rural physician recruitment and retention. Soc Sci Med. 2009;69(9):1368–76.
  64. Wilkinson D, Laven G, Pratt N, Beilby J. Impact of undergraduate and postgraduate rural training, and medical school entry criteria on rural practice among Australian general practitioners: national study of 2414 doctors. Medical education. 2003;37(9):809–14.
  65. Henry JA, Edwards BJ, Crotty B. Why do medical graduates choose rural careers? Rural and Remote Health. 2009;9(1).
  66. Rabinowitz HK, Diamond JJ, Markham FW, Rabinowitz C. Long-term retention of graduates from a program to increase the supply of rural family physicians. Academic medicine: J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2005;80(8):728–32.
  67. WHO. Increasing access to health workers in remote and rural areas through improved retention. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2010.

Most read articles by the same author(s)