Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer
##common.pageHeaderLogo.altText##

Review article: Biomedical intelligence

Vol. 142 No. 3334 (2012)

Controversies in the determination of death: perspectives from Switzerland

  • Settimio Monteverde
  • Annette Rid
DOI
https://doi.org/10.4414/smw.2012.13667
Cite this as:
Swiss Med Wkly. 2012;142:w13667
Published
12.08.2012

Summary

In 1968, an Ad Hoc committee at the Harvard Medical School advanced new criteria for determining death. It proposed that patients in irreversible coma with no discernible central nervous system activity were actually dead. The committee paved the way for the “whole brain” definition of death, which has reached broad public acceptance and legal enactment in many countries. Despite this, the philosophical and ethical debate about the “whole brain” definition of death is far from being closed. This paper analyses the ongoing controversy and evaluates the recent revision of the Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences guidelines for determining death.

References

  1. Pernick MS. Brain death in a cultural context: The reconstruction of death, 1967–1981. In: Arnold RM, Youngner, SJ, Schapiro R (eds). The Definition of Death. Contemporary Controversies. Baltimore: John Hopkins; 1999. p. 3–33.
  2. President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Defining death: a report on the medical, legal, and ethical issues in the determination of death. Washington DC: U.S. Government Printing Office; 1981. Available at: http://bioethics.georgetown.edu/pcbe/reports/past_commissions/defining_death.pdf. Last accessed April 25th, 2012.
  3. Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to examine the definition of brain death. A definition of irreversible coma. JAMA. 1968;205(6):337–40.
  4. Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences (SAMS). The determination of death in the context of organ transplantation. Medical-ethical guidelines. Basel: Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences; 2011. Available at http://www.samw.ch/dms/en/Ethics/Guidelines/Currently-valid-guidelines/e_RL_FeststellungTod_2011/e_RL_FeststellungTod_11.pdf. Last accessed April 20th, 2012.
  5. DeGrazia D. The definition of death. In: Zalta EN (editor). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Fall 2011 edition; 2011. Available at: http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2011/entries/death-definition/. Last accessed April 30th 2012.
  6. DeGrazia D. Human identity and bioethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2005.
  7. Miller FG, Truog RD. Death, dying, and organ transplantation: reconstructing medical ethics at the end of life. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2012.
  8. Wijdicks EF. Brain death worldwide: accepted fact but no global consensus in diagnostic criteria. Neurology. 2002;58(1):20–5.
  9. Wijdicks EFM. The clinical criteria of brain death throughout the world: why has it come to this? Can J Anaesth. 2006;53(6):540–3.
  10. Shewmon DA. Chronic “brain death”: a meta-analysis and conceptual consequences. Neurology. 1998;51(6):1538–45.
  11. Shewmon DA. The brain and somatic integration: insights into the standard rationale for equating “brain death” with death. J Med Phil. 2001;26(5):457–78.
  12. The President’s Council on Bioethics. Controversies in the determination of death. A White Paper of the President’s Council on Bioethics. The President’s Council on Bioethics: Washington, DC; 2008. Available at: http://bioethics.georgetown.edu/pcbe/reports/death/index.html. Last accessed April 30th 2012.
  13. Jonas H. Gehirntod und menschliche Organbank: Zur pragmatischen Umdefinierung des Todes. In: Jonas H (editor). Medizin und Ethik. Praxis des Prinzips Verantwortung. Frankfurt a.M.: Suhrkamp; 1985. p. 219–41.
  14. Hoff J, in der Schmitten J. Kritik der «Hirntod»-Konzeption. Plädoyer für ein menschenwürdiges Todesverständnis. In: Hoff J, in der Schmitten J (editors). Wann ist der Mensch tot? Organverpflanzung und «Hirntod»-Kriterium. Reinbek: Rowohlt, 1995. p. 153–252.
  15. Veatch R. Whole-brain, neocortical, and higher-brain related concepts. In: Zaner RM (editor). Death: beyond whole-brain criteria. Kluwer: Dordrecht; 1988. p. 171–86.
  16. DeVita MA, Snyder JV. Development of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center policy for the care of terminally ill patients who may become organ donors after death following the removal of life support. Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 1993;3(2):131–43.
  17. Boucek MM, Mashburn C, Dunn SM, Frizell R, Edwards L, Pietra B, Campbell D, Denver Children’s Pediatric Heart Transplant Team. Pediatric heart transplantation after declaration of cardiocirculatory death. N Engl J Med. 2008;359(7):709–14.
  18. Petrie DA, De Maio V, Stiell IG, Dreyer J, Martin M, O’Brien JA. Factors affecting survival after prehospital asystolic cardiac arrest in a Basic Life Support-Defibrillation system. CJEM. 2001;3(3):186–92.
  19. Brain Resuscitation Clinical Trial I Study Group: Steering Committee: Abramson NS, Safar P, Detre KM, Kelsey SF, Monroe J, Reinmuth O, Snyder JW. Neurologic recovery after cardiac arrest: effect of duration of ischemia. Cirt Care Med. 1985;13(11):930–1.
  20. Brain Resuscitation Clinical Trial I Study Group. Randomized clinical study of thiopental loading in comatose survivors after cardiac arrest. N Engl J Med. 1989;314(7):397–403.
  21. Brain Resuscitation Clinical Trial II Study Group. A randomized clinical study of a calcium-entry blocker (lidoflazine) in the treatment of comatose survivors of cardiac arrest. N Engl J Med. 1991;324(18):1225–31.
  22. Hornby K, Hornby L, Shemie SD. A systematic review of autoresuscitation after cardiac arrest. Crit Care Med. 2010;38(5):1246–53.
  23. Brock DW. The role of the public in public policy on the definition of death. In: Younger SJ, Arnold RM, Shapiro R (editors). The definition of death: contemporary controversies. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1999. p. 293–308.
  24. Marquis D. Are DCD Donors Dead? Hastings Cent Rep. 2010;40(3):24–31.
  25. Largiadèr F. Transplantation von Organen. Von der Mythologie zur erlebten Gegenwart. Basel: EMH; 2011.
  26. Troehler U. Brain death in Switzerland 1960–2000. Handling a medical innovation. Swiss Med Wkly. 2007;137(Suppl 155):145S–150S.
  27. Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences (SAMS). Richtlinien für die Definition und die Diagnose des Todes [Guidelines for the definition and the diagnosis of death]. In: Jahresbericht 1968 der Schweizerischen Akademie der Medizinischen Wissenschaften. Basel: Schwabe; 1969. p. 541–3, 563–4.
  28. Swiss Confederation. Federal Act on the Transplantation of Organs, Tissues and Cells (Transplantation Act). Available at: http://www.admin.ch/ch/e/rs/810_21/index.html. Last accessed April 30th, 2012.
  29. Beyeler F, Wälchli-Bhend S, Marti HP, Immer F. Wiedereinführung des Non-Heart-Beating-Donor-Programms in der Schweiz? Schweiz Ärztezeitung. 2009;90(23):899–901.
  30. Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences (SAMS). Richtlinien zur Definition und Feststellung des Todes im Hinblick auf Organtransplantationen [Guidelines for the definition and determination of death in the context of organ transplantation]. Schweiz Ärztezeitung. 1996;77(44)1773–81.
  31. Practice parameters for determining brain death in adults (summary statement). The Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology. 1995;45(5):1012–4 (no authors listed).
  32. Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences (SAMS). Feststellung des Todes mit Bezug auf Organtransplantationen. Medizin-ethische Richtlinien [Determination of death in relation to organ transplants. Medical-ethical guidelines]. Schweiz Ärztezeitung. 2005;86(31):1859–63.
  33. Wijdicks EF, Varelas PN, Gronseth GS, Greer DM; American Academy of Neurology. Evidence-based guideline update: determining brain death in adults: report of the Quality. Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology. 2010;74 (23):1911–8.
  34. Varelas PN, Rehman M, Abdelhak T, Patel A, Rai V, Barber A, et al. Single brain death examination is equivalent to dual brain death examinations. Neurocrit Care. 2011;15(3):547–53.
  35. Safar P, Stezowski W, Nemoto EM. Amelioration of brain damage after 12 minutes’ cardiac arrest in dogs. Arch Neurol. 1976;33(2):91–5.
  36. Safar P, Behringer W, Böttiger B, Sterz F. Cerebral resuscitation potentials for cardiac arrest. Crit Care Med. 2002;30(4):S140–4.
  37. Lustbader D, O’Hara D, Wijdicks EF, MacLean L, Tajik W, Ying A, et al. Second brain death examination may negatively affect organ donation. Neurology. 2011;76(2):119–24.
  38. Truog RD. Is it time to abandon brain death? Hastings Cent Rep. 1997;27(1):29–37.
  39. Veatch RM. The impending collapse of the whole-brain definition of death. Hastings Cent Rep. 1993;23(4):18–24.
  40. Fagerlin A, Schneider CE. Enough. The failure of the living will. Hastings Cent Rep. 2004;34(2):30–42.
  41. Wolff J. Ethics and public policy: a philosophical inquiry. New York: Taylor & Francis; 2011.
  42. Dubois JM. The ethics of creating and responding to doubts about death criteria. J Med Philos. 2010; 35(3):365–80.

Most read articles by the same author(s)