Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer

Original article

Vol. 141 No. 1516 (2011)

Systematic comparison of the effectiveness of percutaneous mitral balloon valvotomy with surgical mitral commissurotomy

  • Q Zhao
  • X Hu
DOI
https://doi.org/10.4414/smw.2011.13180
Cite this as:
Swiss Med Wkly. 2011;141:w13180
Published
11.04.2011

Abstract

PRINCIPLES: Percutaneous mitral balloon valvotomy is increasingly being carried out on patients with pure mitral stenosis, but discrepant results are still available at long-term follow-ups following percutaneous balloon and traditional surgical valvotomy. This research sought to systematically compare the efficacy and safety of mitral balloon and surgical valvotomy.

METHODS: A systematic literature retrieval was performed for all clinical trials comparing the outcomes of mitral valvotomy with balloon intervention or surgery in Pubmed, EMBASE and the Cochrane Library.

RESULTS: A total of 12 eligible, clinical studies, comparing mitral valvotomy using percutaneous balloon intervention or thoracotomy surgery, were found between 1966 and 2010: seven prospective randomised trials and five case-control trials. With follow-up ranging from one to seven years, there was no significant difference in mortality (relative risk (RR) 0.97, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.45–2.09) and complications (RR 2.15, 95% CI 0.98–4.7) between the two procedures. The pooling analysis obtained a significantly higher occurrence of new-onset mitral regurgitation after percutaneous balloon intervention relative to thoracotomy surgery (RR 1.66 95%CI 1.08–2.58). Similarly, we obtained a higher RR of re-intervention in balloon intervention compared to thoracotomy surgery of 2.88 (95% CI 1.97–4.2). In addition, compared to those patients who had thoracotomy surgery, patients who underwent percutaneous balloon intervention presented a significantly worse effect in preserving the mitral valve area: SMD –0.30, 95%CI: –0.42 - –0.18.

CONCLUSIONS: Clinical evidence suggests there are comparable clinical outcomes in terms of operative, late mortality and complications between percutaneous balloon and surgical mitral commissurotomy. Incidences of new-onset mitral regurgitation and late re-intervention are significantly higher after balloon intervention.

References

  1. Carapetis JR, McDonald M, Wilson NJ. Acute rheumatic fever. Lancet. 2005;366:155–68.
  2. Inoue K, Owaki T, Nakamura T, Kitamura F, Miyamoto N. Clinical application of transvenous mitral commissurotomy by a new balloon catheter. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1984;87:394–402.
  3. Song JK, Kim MJ, Yun SC, Choo SJ, Song JM, Song H, et al. Long-term outcomes of percutaneous mitral balloon valvuloplasty versus open cardiac surgery. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2010;139(1):103–10.
  4. Cotrufo M, Renzulli A, Ismeno G, Caruso A, Mauro C, Caso P, De Simone L, Violini R. Percutaneous mitral commissurotomy versus open mitral commissurotomy: a comparative study. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 1999;15(5):646–51.
  5. Rifaie O, Abdel-Dayem MK, Ramzy A, Ezz-El-Din H, El-Ziady G, El-Itriby A, et al. Percutaneous mitral valvotomy versus closed surgical commissurotomy. Up to 15 years of follow-up of a prospective randomized study. J Cardiol. 2009;53(1):28–34.
  6. Jadad AR, Moore RA, Carroll D. Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary? Control Clin Trials. 1996;17:1–12.
  7. Clarke M,OxmanAD. Cochrane reviewer’s handbook 4.1.3 [updated June 2001]. In: The Cochrane Library, Issue 3: Oxford: Update Software, 2001.
  8. Cardoso LF, Grinberg M, Pomerantzeff PM, Rati MA, Medeiros CC, Vieira ML, et al. Comparison of open commissurotomy and balloon valvuloplasty in mitral stenosis. A five-year follow-up. Arq Bras Cardiol. 2004;83(3):248–52.
  9. Cardoso LF, Grinberg M, Rati MA, Pomerantzeff PM, Medeiros CC, Tarasoutchi F, Martinez E. Comparison between percutaneous balloon valvuloplasty and open commissurotomy for mitral stenosis. A prospective and randomized study. Cardiology. 2002;98(4):186–90.
  10. Ismeno G, Renzulli A, De Feo M, Della Corte A, Mauro C, Romano G, Mininni N, Cotrufo M. Surgery of rheumatic mitral stenosis: comparison of different techniques. Acta Cardiol. 2001;56(3):155–61.
  11. Tokmakoglu H, Vural KM, Ozatik MA, Cehreli S, Sener E, Tasdemir O. Closed commissurotomy versus balloon valvuloplasty for rheumatic mitral stenosis. J Heart Valve Dis. 2001;10(3):281–7.
  12. Ommen SR, Nishimura RA, Grill DE, Holmes DR Jr, Rihal CS. Comparison of long-term results of percutaneous mitral balloon valvotomy with closed transventricular mitral commissurotomy at a single North American Institution. Am J Cardiol. 1999;84(5):575–7.
  13. Cardoso LF, Rati MA, Pomerantzeff PM, Medeiros CC, Tarasoutchi F, Rossi EG, et al. Comparison between percutaneous balloon valvuloplasty and open commissurotomy for mitral stenosis [Article in Portuguese] Arq Bras Cardiol. 1998;70(6):415–21.
  14. Ben Farhat M, Ayari M, Maatouk F, Betbout F, Gamra H, Jarra M, et al. Percutaneous balloon versus surgical closed and open mitral commissurotomy: seven-year follow-up results of a randomized trial. Circulation. 1998;97(3):245–50.
  15. Raju S Iyer, Rajnish Jain, Manoj Padmanabhan, Abha Chandra, Sanjeev Agarwal, et al. Closed Mitral Valvotomy Versus Balloon Valvuloplasty: A Comparison of 100 Cases. Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann. 1998;6:285–7.
  16. Essop R, Rothlisberger C, Dullabh A, Sareli P. Can the long-term outcomes of percutaneous balloon mitral valvotomy and surgical commissurotomy be expected to be similar? J Heart Valve Dis. 1995;4(5):446–52.
  17. Olmos A, Seguel I, Gajardo J, Ghyra A, Santander C, Alarcón E, et al. Percutaneous mitral valvuloplasty and open mitral commissurotomy: comparison of 2 techniques in immediate results [Article in Spanish] Rev Med Chil. 1994;122(3):274–82.
  18. Reyes VP, Raju BS, Wynne J, Stephenson LW, Raju R, Fromm BS, et al. Percutaneous balloon valvuloplasty compared with open surgical commissurotomy for mitral stenosis. N Engl J Med. 1994;331(15):961–7.
  19. Arora R, Nair M, Kalra GS, Nigam M, Khalilullah M. Immediate and long-term results of balloon and surgical closed mitral valvotomy: a randomized comparative study. Am Heart J. 1993;125(4):1091–4.
  20. Cohen JM, Glower DD, Harrison JK, Bashore TM, White WD, Smith LR, et al. Comparison of balloon valvuloplasty with operative treatment for mitral stenosis. Ann Thorac Surg. 1993;56(6):1254–62.
  21. Shrivastava S, Mathur A, Dev V, Saxena A, Venugopal P, SampathKumar A. Comparison of immediate hemodynamic response to closed mitral commissurotomy, single-balloon, and double-balloon mitral valvuloplasty in rheumatic mitral stenosis. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1992;104(5):1264–7.
  22. Momomura S, Takenaka K, Serizawa T, Chikada M, Kotsuka H, Matsunoga H, Furuse A. Percutaneous transvenous, mitral commissurotomy versus open mitral commissurotomy. [Article in Japanese] Nippon Geka Gakkai Zasshi. 1992;93(9):1016–9.
  23. Patel JJ, Shama D, Mitha AS, Blyth D, Hassen F, Le Roux BT, Chetty S. Balloon valvuloplasty versus closed commissurotomy for pliable mitral stenosis: a prospective hemodynamic study. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1991;18(5):1318–22.
  24. Turi ZG, Reyes VP, Raju BS, Raju AR, Kumar DN, Rajagopal P, et al. Percutaneous balloon versus surgical closed commissurotomy for mitral stenosis. A prospective, randomized trial. Circulation. 1991;83(4):1179–85.
  25. Kirklin JW. Percutaneous balloon versus surgical closed commissurotomy for mitral stenosis. Circulation. 1991;83(4):1450–1.
  26. Grinberg M, Bellotti G, Pileggi F. Aspectos do planejamento terapêutico na estenose mitral. Arq Bras Cardiol. 1983;51:289–95.
  27. Iung B, Garbarz E, Michaud P, Mahdhaoui A, Helou S, Farah B, et al. Percutaneous mitral commissurotomy for restenosis after surgical commissurotomy: late efficacy and implications for patient selection. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2000;35(5):1295–302.
  28. Essop R, Rothlisberger C, Dullabh A, Sareli P. Can the long term outcomes of percutaneous ballon mitral valvotomy and surgical commissurotomy be expected to be similar? J Heart Valve Dis. 1995;4:446±45
  29. Black MD, Campagna M, Bedard P, Marquis JF, Walley VM. Severe mitral insufficiency post-balloon valvuloplsty: The late changes found in a disrupted mitral valve. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn. 1990;21:99–102.
  30. Acar C, Jebara VA, Grare P, Chachques JC, Dervanian P, Vahanian A, Carpentier A. Traumatic mitral insufficiency following percutaneous mitral dilation: anatomic lesions and surgical implications. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 1992;6(12):660–3.